Stuck at home on my 1st level recovering from a broken knee after a fall, I recently started binging on the show Beachfront Bargain Hunt. This single mom was viewing homes in a beachfront town on the east coast. I noticed the realtor there said “blah blah..escalation clause with our offer…” with a grin thinking she just reinvented the wheel. It instantly wanted me to write a blog about this topic. So what IS an escalation clause? Well, for starters, in Houston right now, it’s a pretty balanced market but tends to lean towards the sellers side. I haven't heard agents using this tactic lately but I think it’s a fascinating topic to discuss. Buyers agents haven't been adding contingency or escalation clauses to their offers so I haven't thought about this strategy in a while.
Is it a good idea to add an escalation clause to your offer? This one is for all the naïve buyers and sellers out there who think an escalation clause is a good idea. It's a terrible idea, but let me just tell it like it is. It’s wrong for most residential contracts. Let me break it down for you.
An Escalation Clause is wording in a contract that states the potential buyer is willing to go above a certain amount. For example, a buyer may agree to pay $1,000 more than the next highest offer received by a seller.
In theory, it’s fairly simple….an escalation clause is basically designed to strengthen a buyer’s offer in a multiple offer situation.
The buyer offers a certain price for the property, but if the seller receives another offer that is higher, this buyer is willing to increase their offer up to a point. Escalation clauses are a tactic used by some buyers to make their offer more appealing and ensure the seller will choose their offer.
It might sound like a good idea for a buyer trying to win in a bidding war and an even better idea for the seller looking for the highest sales price. Sellers welcome buyers willing to pay more than anyone else. So why does the Texas Association of Realtors strongly discourage the use of escalation clauses? Why are they frowned upon by so many real estate industry leaders?
There is so much can go wrong with an escalation clause in a real estate contract and inherent problems frequently surface when buyers and sellers use them. Some examples of the problems with escalation clauses are:
An escalation clause is like asking a buyer to open their wallet or show all their cards, or in this case, all their money and "you can take it if you want it"! Most buyers want a cap on the escalation offer to keep from paying more than they are willing for the property. Often the buyer will state they are willing to pay X dollars more than the next highest offer not to exceed $Y. In that case, why wouldn’t the seller just counter the offer at that capped price? It would take the guess work out of the equation. In my experience, the seller sees the capped offer price and that is what they now want to get. The seller’s expectations become established once the buyer has disclosed how much they are willing to pay for the property.
Contracts are confidential to the parties named in the contract. If another offer is received, the terms of that offer may not be disclosed without written consent from buyer and seller. Realtors are allowed to disclose when there are multiple offers, but not allowed to reveal the amounts to other parties. It is unethical for a seller or their agent to reveal the terms of a contract without permission from that buyer. Which brings us to the next issue. How does the buyer know what they are truly competing against?
Proof of another offer becomes tricky. The buyer with an escalation clause offer doesn’t really know if the next highest offer is legitimate. Are they really competing against another bona fide offer and not just a phony offer solicited by the seller to raise the price for their property? It could be impossible for the buyer to verify that another offer is sincere or genuine and not just a friend or relative of the seller. The buyer basically has no assurances and is stuck outbidding something they can’t confirm.
The seller’s agent has a duty to get the best deal for the seller. If multiple offers are received on a property, You might hear the phrase "resubmit your highest and best Offer". If one or more offers includes an escalation clause, at what point do you have a specific dollar amount offer that represents the highest sales price that could be obtained? Hopefully the parties include a deadline for determining the sales price.
An exact sales price must be agreed upon at some point. When buyer and seller accept a contract with an escalation clause, the sales price could be $1,000, $10,000, $100,000 or more over the buyer’s original offer. Both buyer and seller become locked in to the contract when it is executed. The sales price and terms should be clear so both buyer and seller can rely on it.
Sellers should realize that until the contract is finalized and executed (everyone has signed off), a buyer’s offer with an escalation clause is really just the buyer requesting a free right-of-first refusal. This is why most savvy home sellers will not accept an offer with an escalation clause and will only consider an offer with an exact dollar amount and clear terms.
So with that said, this can all be avoided, and MUCH less paperwork and all the back and forth with an experienced negotiator like myself. If your a homebuyer Your listing agent should educate you and multiple scenarios that could arise when selling your home and if your a Realtor as your Buyers Agent, you should have a game plan ans strategy and explore all options you can use to make your offer stronger and more competitive. and sometimes this starts months before you go on house hunting because it may start at the Preapproval stage.
Lastly, If the buyer has an option period, they may use that to terminate the contract if they feel stuck with a higher purchase price than they had planned. Then the seller is back to square one with hopes of fielding other offers. Home sellers are wise to remember that the best offer is not always based on purchase price alone. It is also important you use an experienced agent for buying or selling a home. If you have any questions please give me a ring or leave me a comment below! I would love to hear from you. Or you’re an Agent in Texas. I’d love to hear your thoughts & comments if you have experienced an escalation clause scenario too.
Aubrie Layne is a licensed Realtor in Houston Texas with Martha Turner Sotheby's International Realty. To search for properties, get more selling, buying, design hacks and tips, visit aubrielayne.com
Email her at aubrie.layne@sothebys.realty
Call/Text 281-773-4259
Did you like this post? Leave me your comments below! For shopping lists of my favorite products for cleaning and organizing, visit my Amazon Affiliate page!
Some of the content in this blog may have been generated by technology known as Artificial Intelligence or “AI”. Therefore, please note that the information provided may not be error-free or up to date. You should not rely on the content for any legal purposes or use. I disclaim any responsibility or liability for your use or interpretation of the content provided. Clicking these links may be tied to an affiliate and may earn me a tiny commission-I only share products I adore, but alas, I cant promise your results will be the same level of awesomeness. It's the internet, not a magic wand!